Buildings insurance covers the cost of rebuilding your home if it is destroyed. That figure is not what the house would sell for, and confusing the two is the single most common mistake in home insurance.
Rebuild cost is not market value
The sale price of a property includes the land it sits on, and the location. If a house burns down, the land is still there. What has been lost is the structure, so what needs insuring is the cost of building it again.
For most properties the rebuild cost is lower than the market value, sometimes substantially so, because land accounts for so much of the price in desirable areas. Insuring for the sale price means paying for cover you can never use.
The reverse happens too. Period properties, listed buildings, thatched roofs, stone construction and remote locations can all cost more to rebuild than they would fetch, because the materials and craftsmanship are expensive and the site is awkward.
What the rebuild figure has to include
People underestimate because they think only of walls and a roof. A realistic rebuild sum insured covers:
- Demolition and clearing the site of what is left.
- Architects, surveyors, structural engineers and planning fees.
- Materials and labour at current prices, which have moved considerably in recent years.
- Meeting current building regulations, which are usually stricter than those in force when the house was built.
- Outbuildings, garages, walls, fences, gates, drives, paths and permanent fixtures such as fitted kitchens and bathrooms.
How to arrive at a number
For a standard modern house of conventional brick construction, the free rebuilding cost calculator published by the Building Cost Information Service of the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors is the usual starting point. It works from the type of property, its age, its floor area and its location. Many insurers accept it directly.
Measure the floor area properly rather than estimating, and include every storey and any extension.
Get a professional valuation instead if the property is unusual. Listed buildings, homes with thatch, timber frame or stone walls, converted barns, flats above shops and anything with restricted access all fall outside what a general calculator can handle. A chartered surveyor will produce a reinstatement cost assessment, and the fee is small against the consequence of getting it wrong.
Underinsurance and how it bites
If your sum insured is lower than the true rebuild cost, insurers apply what is known as average. The principle is that if you insured for half of what you should have, you paid roughly half the premium you should have, so the insurer pays a proportionately reduced share of any claim.
This applies to all claims, not only total losses. A kitchen fire costing 30,000 pounds to put right, on a property insured for 60 per cent of its rebuild cost, could see the payout cut by 40 per cent. Underinsurance is not a problem that stays hidden until the house falls down; it surfaces the first time you claim for anything.
Keeping the figure current
Most policies index-link the sum insured, adjusting it each year in line with a building cost index. That helps with general inflation but knows nothing about your house.
Review the figure yourself whenever you make a structural change: an extension, a loft or garage conversion, a conservatory, a new outbuilding, or a significantly upgraded kitchen or bathroom. Tell your insurer at the time rather than waiting for renewal.
Flats and leasehold
If you own a flat, the building is usually insured by the freeholder or the management company under a block policy, and the cost is recovered through your service charge. You generally need contents insurance only.
Ask to see the block policy schedule and check that the sum insured is realistic, since the same underinsurance rules apply to the whole building and any shortfall eventually reaches leaseholders.
The short version
Insure for what it costs to rebuild, not what it would sell for. Use the RICS calculator for a standard property and a surveyor for anything unusual. Update the figure after building work, and remember that underinsurance reduces every claim, not just the big one.
One further point worth knowing: some policies offer unlimited or bedroom-rated cover, where the insurer sets the sum insured based on the number of bedrooms rather than asking you for a figure. That removes the underinsurance risk, which is genuinely useful, but check what it excludes before assuming it solves the problem entirely.