Back to Claims

Why Insurance Claims Are Refused, and What to Do

Why Insurance Claims Are Refused, and What to Do
Insurance Basics Team 31 July 2026

A refused claim feels final. It usually is not. Insurers get decisions wrong, and there is a free, independent route to challenge them that most policyholders never use.

The common reasons for refusal

Non-disclosure. Something was not declared when the policy was taken out or renewed: a medical condition, a previous claim, a conviction, a business run from home, who really drives the car. This is the largest single category.

An exclusion applies. The loss is a type the policy never covered. Wear and tear, gradual damage, damp, mechanical failure and lack of maintenance are the usual ones, and they appear in almost every policy.

A condition was not met. Policies impose obligations: fitting particular locks, setting an alarm, not leaving a property unoccupied beyond a stated number of days, reporting theft to the police within a time limit, servicing a boiler. Breaching one can defeat an otherwise valid claim.

Late notification. Most policies require notification within a specified period. Delay gives the insurer grounds if it prejudiced their ability to investigate.

Insufficient evidence. No receipts, no crime reference number, no photographs, or the damaged item disposed of before it was inspected.

Underinsurance. Not always a refusal, but a proportionate reduction that can feel like one.

Which refusals are worth challenging

Non-disclosure is more arguable than it looks. Under the Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012, the test is whether you took reasonable care not to make a misrepresentation, and the insurer's remedy depends on whether the error was careless or deliberate. A careless mistake that would only have increased your premium should result in a proportionately reduced payout, not a flat refusal.

Ambiguous wording is also arguable. If a policy term is genuinely capable of two readings, that generally works against the party that wrote it.

Conversely, a claim for something the policy plainly excludes is unlikely to succeed however unfair it feels.

Get the decision in writing

Before anything else, ask the insurer to set out in writing exactly why the claim was refused, quoting the specific clause in the policy wording they are relying on.

This matters for two reasons. It forces them to identify a precise contractual basis rather than a general impression, and it gives you something concrete to check against your own documents. Refusals sometimes cite terms that are not in the version of the policy you were sold.

Making a complaint

Every regulated insurer must have a formal complaints procedure, and using it is a required step before escalating.

  • Put the complaint in writing and say clearly that it is a complaint.
  • Set out what happened, why you believe the decision is wrong, and what you want done.
  • Attach your evidence and reference the policy clause you rely on.
  • Keep copies of everything, and note the date you sent it.

The firm has eight weeks to give you a final response. If they uphold the refusal, that letter is your final response letter, and you need it for the next stage.

The Financial Ombudsman Service

If you are still unhappy after a final response, or eight weeks have passed without one, you can take the case to the Financial Ombudsman Service.

It is free to consumers. You do not need a solicitor, and you should not pay a claims management company to do something you can do yourself. The Ombudsman looks at what is fair and reasonable in the circumstances, not solely at the strict contract wording, which is why it sometimes finds for consumers where a court might not.

Its decision is binding on the firm if you accept it. If you reject it, you keep your right to go to court.

Time limits apply: generally six months from the final response letter, and six years from the event. Do not sit on it.

What helps your case

Contemporaneous evidence, kept from the start. Photographs before anything is repaired or cleared away, receipts, the crime reference number, dated notes of every phone call with the name of who you spoke to, and the policy documents as they were issued when you bought the cover.

Keep the tone factual. Complaints that set out a clear sequence of events, quote the relevant clause and state plainly what outcome is sought do better than angry ones, both with the insurer and at the Ombudsman.

And do not accept a first offer simply because it arrived. A partial settlement can usually be disputed on the same grounds as a refusal, using exactly the same complaints route.